Very good pizza. The ownership changed and i like the new ownership better as better service. Fast ordering and good food.
Much better than your typical pizza chain. Good to have a pizzeria in town. Happy & helpful staff!
I'm not a big fan of Utah food, so I usually stick to chain restaurants. And sometimes even those are awful here. I'm a huge pizza eater, pizza is my food of choice. This place is amazing. The hot wings aren't hot at all, FYI, but the flavor is delicious. I'll be coming to this place again and again for pizza. The bottom of the crust is nice and crisp and the edges are chewy and soft. The sauce is a little sweeter than other pizzas but it's still tasty and delicious. I highly recommend trying this place.
DO NOT GO if you are expecting the Nicolitalia pizza and breadsticks served prior to the change of location and ownership. They claim the recipes are the same, but even if so, they do not know how to execute them properly. The new staff has a tenuous grasp of the English language so communication can be an issue as well--just read some of the current owner responses to reviews and you will know what I mean. Never had to really talk to the old staff as my order was always properly filled and the product was extremely satisfying. Never going back under current circumstances. Old owner should be ashamed to be connected in any way to this perversion of a once great pizza restaurant.
The best place in Provo to get pizza. Their breadsticks are out of this world and when you add their house sauce, don’t even get me started! I love their Margarita Pizza!
They moved from previous location, and it was good to dining tables. But, I looked forward to a good bite as I was accustomed to, settled on Stromboli, as it was the daily special. Wished I would have gone with pizza which I know is pretty good. The Stromboli was not all that great.
This is our favorite pizza in Utah County. Many people won't go because they don't sell it by the slice but they do personal pizzas and even if you get a larger one you won't regret it. Literally everything is good but our favorite is the Italian Stallion and we get it with house dressing on the side. It is the best!!! They also have great weekly specials posted on their website.
Amazing, authentic pizza made with noticeably fresh ingredients. The staff are friendly, and the atmosphere is just right for relaxation. Best pizza in town!
Excellent Pizzeria. Crust is tasty and good texture while chewed. Decent price. The house special hot sauce is amazing! The only reason I didn't give a 5-star is due to lack of hand soap in the bathroom.
Best pizza place in Provo by far. We take everyone we know here that is visiting from out of town because it is so delicious. Everyone loves it. We constantly eat from here. If you want good pizza you need to eat here.
Terrible pizza and waste of my money and time. I loved the old Nicolitalia. I had relatives in town and was excited to show them quality pizza in Provo. They got our order wrong and rather than getting it right by making us a new pizza, they put the correct toppings on and "heated up" the pizza. We were peeved. They argued that they got our order correct in the first place and then went in the back and chatted together. There were only 2 other customers dining. They could have corrected their mistake properly. Our pizza looked disgusting after they heated it up with the correct toppings. Don't go there unless you like expensive pizza with Little Ceasars quality.
I came here with 3 friends to celebrate a birthday. We used a Groupon and got a really good deal. The pizza's had a nice crust on the thinner side and the pizzas themselves were full of flavor. The service was fast and the restaurant clean. The location could be better along with the interior. I would definitely recommend to anyone looking for above average pizza.