This restaurant, in my opinion, is the best in New Paltz. Been to A Tavola a dozen times or more. It is called Italian but don't expect traditional Italian food. Do expect the best cooking fresh from the farm and large selection of fine wine for a region far from Manhattan competition. The service is impeccable. I recently brought a group of friends and the compliments on my selection were the best possible.
Food delicious Service excellent Atmosphere great
A Tavola is an awesome restaurant right in the heart of New Paltz. The ambiance is cozy, the cocktails are creative and delicious and the food is awesome. The antipasti special is always a treat (they change it every evening), the octopus and beet salad are also favorites and make sure you save some room for dessert! Also there's plenty of room to eat at the bar/in the bar area.
Had a very nice experience here. The food was delicious! The menu is a bit different then a typical restaurant more of a traditional Italian in terms of the courses. My favorite was the Tortellini! Also the Beets and the Fish Special were amazing.
This restaurant does not only offer great food but also a very elegant experience. They clear the tables down to the crumb between each course. They check in with you often but not overdone.
Hope you enjoy!
We dined as a group of ten. From making the reservation to paying the bill, every aspect of my experience was really great. The food was great. The menu was a twist from traditional Italian and the service was spectacular.
Excellent steak..excellent meal..great initial service.. 20+ minutes to get check after table cleared and check request.. No exaggeration.. No embellishments.. Local resident.. Easy fix for management
Fantastic service, excellent food. We enjoyed a little bit of everything the menu had to offer, but we especially enjoyed the squid ink pasta. The calamari was cooked to perfection and the food presentation was pristine. The wait staff were very knowledgeable and helpful. We asked our waitress to help us pair drinks with our meal and she did a great job. I will definitely be coming back.
I always love eating here the food is farm to table and reservations are recommended always here as it is fully packed the Ribeye is excellent here
I have eaten here several times and have never been disappointed. Attentive service and excellent food.
One of the two or three nicest restaurants in the New Paltz area. Very good food, generally Mediterranean in style. Consistent and friendly service (which can be a challenge in some area restaurants since many of the servers are students doing the job on a part time / temporary basis, rather than experienced professional waiters). A nice place to go for an evening out, but plan on making reservations.
They really are a five star restaurant. It comes with a five star price. $100 for two people. The food was incredible. Farm to table locally sourced. Cozy upstairs seating was romantic for my wife and I.