• Delete
  • Edit

About

Tuthill House at the Mill is a bar, located at 20 Grist Mill Ln, Gardiner, NY 12525, USA. They can be contacted via phone at +1 845-255-1527, visit their website www.tuthillhouse.com for more detailed information.

Location :
20 Grist Mill Ln, Gardiner, NY 12525, USA
Added by Jopie, at 18 September 2016

Opening Hours

  • Monday 5:00 – 9:00 PM
  • Tuesday Closed
  • Wednesday Closed
  • Thursday 5:00 – 9:00 PM
  • Friday 12:00 – 10:00 PM
  • Saturday 12:00 – 10:00 PM
  • Sunday 12:00 – 8:00 PM

Add missing information

Add email
Add business description
Add Social Media
Add Products and Services

13 Reviews

  • Larissa Hug
    11 December 2017

    The service was great! We had a wonderful, informative waitress. The food was really good but the cocktails were even better. The prices r high but at least u know it's going to be good

    response / report this review
  • Bob Kerrigan
    03 November 2017

    I did not enjoy my experience at Tuthilltown. The place wasn't crowded when we first arrived, yet we waited over an hour for the meals. When it finally did arrive the food was good but not great. My steak had clearly been left sitting around cooling off and, although I don't require a huge feeding, this portion was stingy and disappointing.

    Another detail, that perhaps only I would find annoying, my bourbon on the rocks was clearly measured out to be precisely one jigger. They produce decent bourbon there, but for the money it costs, they should part with the stuff a bit more freely.

    The staff was apologetic but, with all of the great restaurants in the area, I will not be going back in a hurry.

    response / report this review
  • Robert Struck
    30 October 2017

    The food was awesome. The atmosphere and decor were cool and country themed. The service was good, the staff friendly, and the distillery was also great.

    response / report this review
  • Conrad Mossl
    24 October 2017

    I was sad to see that my experience here didn't live up to my expectations. The venue is beautiful and the food was great, but the service was just really disappointing. It look about half an hour to get seated and then we weren't served for another twenty minutes. Some of the items I wanted from the menu were not available and substitutes were not available. The cheese plate we ordered had half of the amount of cheese that we ordered but somehow had twice the bread to go along with it. At the end of the night, we were charged for items we never had received. If I ever return, I'm really routing for a better experience from this very well-known local hot spot.

    response / report this review
  • Chris Arndt
    21 October 2017

    Great place for handcrafted cocktails. They get busy and tend to take a while to make the drink - even when there are four bartenders behind the bar. Nevertheless, they are worth it (approx $12-14)/drink. Justin is an amazing bartender!

    response / report this review
  • Michael Worth
    14 October 2017

    Fantastic experience. Great service, wonderful bar service, food was excellently prepared. Would highly recommend.

    response / report this review
  • Johnathan Hagen
    08 September 2017

    Gorgeous space on the river with delicious food. Sit outside if you can, or enjoy the beautiful old mill.

    response / report this review
  • David Robbins
    06 July 2017

    Simply some of the best food we've eaten in years! Cannot recommend this restaurant too highly. Everything freshly prepared to the highest standard possible. Service excellent!

    Beautifull surroundings too.

    response / report this review
  • Valerie Dare
    02 April 2017

    Love the charcuterie and cheese boards. Specialty cocktails are exceptional. Lioco Chardonnay by the glass! We're moving into the area and this is our go-to place!

    response / report this review
  • Caroline Schlee
    12 March 2017

    Beautiful ambiance with wooden details and soft fairly lights. Very friendly staff and inventive tasty food.

    response / report this review
  • Gerald Pantano
    21 January 2017

    The drinks were good the hamburger platter was very good and the people at the gardener association meeting that was really good. All in all it was a great event. CHEERS!

    response / report this review
  • Kyha Kroll
    08 January 2017

    Food was amazing! The presentation was beautiful.

    response / report this review
  • Benny Nieves
    25 September 2016

    Located on beautiful and historic grounds. Part restaurant, part distillery. Food is good but service is a bit slow. Pick up a bottle of their baby bourbon while you are there.

    response / report this review

Rate & Write Reviews