Pete's Pizza

Location :

2919 US-206, Columbus, NJ 08022, USA
Added by Jopie, at 08 August 2016

Add email
Add business description
Add website
Add Social Media
Add Products and Services

• Andrew Podobed

  12 November 2017

  Unfortunately i have to change my review. This used to be the best sicilian pie in existance but lately the pizzas i have been getting have been very inconsistant, usually having to do with the sauce. either there is too much sauce the crust gets soggy (and makes it an extremely messy food) or the sauce seems to be watered down (sometimes it is a strange pinkish color) its a shame as i really like this place. Gonna have to give Kate and Al's a shot (Theyre owned or used to be owned by the same family so i dont know if theyve also changed)

  response / report this review
• Jessica Chesney

  06 September 2017

  Pie is great and service is always quick/helpful!

  response / report this review
• Jordan Allison

  06 September 2017

  Great Tomato pie, different from most pizza in the area. Service is always quick and the pie is always fresh.

  response / report this review
• Tom Lavoie

  24 July 2017

  Fresh hot tomato pie, excellent service!

  response / report this review
• Anna S

  03 July 2017

  The pizza is so-so. It changed over the last 2 to 3 years. Mostly dough & sauce, very little cheese. The service lacks enthusiasm. I waited over 5 minutes, & there was only 2 people in line ahead of me (several at the counter), then 20 minutes for the pie! I remember when the cute little Asian lady ran the place & service was phenomenal. I don't think I'll be returning often as much if at all. Sorry guys. I'll be trying Kate & Al's. If they don't do better I'll be looking for another place.

  response / report this review
• JoAnn Palladino

  25 April 2017

  My favorite pizza ever!! Drive really far for it and always worth it. Love, love , love it

  response / report this review
• Cristoph Klevoptvic

  27 March 2017

  Best pizza ever if your in the area you must stop to get a few slices you won't regret it!

  response / report this review
• Joseph Pratico

  14 March 2017

  I love there pizza, it is like a tomato pie. I ask for mine to be crispy. If I am at the Columbus market, I am stopping at Pete's.

  response / report this review
• Lauren Sanders

  15 December 2016

  Best pizza ever!! They need to deliver it to Florida :(

  response / report this review
• Thomas Sawyer

  12 December 2016

  Amazing pizza don't know how they do it but it gets better and better

  response / report this review
• Carole Rosario

  15 August 2016

  Very unique flavor and always consistent. So good!

  response / report this review