About
Location :
Added by Jopie, at 20 July 2016
Opening Hours
- Monday Closed
- Tuesday 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Wednesday 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Thursday 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Friday 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Saturday 10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Sunday Closed
Gallery
Add missing information
14 Reviews
-
01 December 2017
OMG This place is wonderful. Call ahead to order what you want, or stop and pick up from daily selection. Sugar creme is great, favorite at our house. Very reasonable price.
response / report this review -
30 November 2017
World famous pies and they are the best in the area. Wonderful selection. Must order early for the holidays.
response / report this review -
26 November 2017
I had not heard of a sugar cream pie. My wife picked one up at the farmers market. We were very disappointed to say the least. Pie had absolutely no flavor. The only flavor was from the cinnamon sprinkled on the top. Have since heard the same complaints from other people. Definitely won't go back. And we have a sugar cream pie since then from somewhere else and it was to die for. Also very rich. But tasty.
response / report this review -
08 November 2017
Worth the trip if you don't live locally. Blue Ribbon pies and cobblers of all sorts
response / report this review -
07 September 2017
The best even let me get a pick up after they closed 1 1/2. The staff are the best
response / report this review -
01 August 2017
We were disappointed after hearing about this place for years. The sugar cream pie was flavorless and gelatinous. The Apple pie was smothered in dry, powdery topping that ruined the whole thing. We took these pies as hostess gifts and they ended up largely uneaten and thrown away. The m&m cookies, on the other hand, were delicious with a surprising texture that was both crisp and chewy. Be warned that this place is out in the middle of nowhere and does not have a restroom, or take credit cards as others have mentioned.
response / report this review -
27 June 2017
Their crust is light and flaky.every pie I've gotten has been delectable, and they do not skimp on the ingredients. The pies are full size. Some are a little heavy from so much filling
response / report this review -
23 June 2017
Nothing but pure goodness comes from this place. The peanut butter pie was to die for. I recommend this place to everyone.
response / report this review -
19 June 2017
They would have had my money if they took credit card. Be warned: CASH ONLY at this establishment. Pies look delicious, but I rarely carry cash. Looks like I'll have to stop by an ATM before visiting my family in Indy.
I think Lisa would get a bunch more money if she accepted credit cards!! Just some advice ;)response / report this review -
19 March 2017
Great variety, smiling faces and great service.
Can't wait for strawberry rhubarb pie.response / report this review -
18 March 2017
If you have not had a pie from Lisa's pie you are missing out.. stop what you are doing and drive up thereyes they are that good
response / report this review -
05 March 2017
Originally we had a problem with a gift certificate, but after talking with Lisa, she helped us out a lot and smoothed things out. Great customer service, and very very good pies! Be warned, they do not take credit cards, so come with cash.
response / report this review -
31 August 2016
We was passing through and this place looked pretty good to stop an get a treat from. We pulled in and parked right in front of the establishment and seen the "closed" sign. Right as we was about to put the vehicle into reverse a van was backing out and came inches from backing get into us. If my husband wouldn't of yelled they would of kept on goin. Instead of getting an apoligy WE get yelled at " YOUR IN MY PARKINGLOT" WOW. This lady about slams into us an yes at us for it and I am assuming it was someone who worked there. Glad they was closed an I didn't wante a min more of my time or money at that place. As far as I am concerned LISA can take her pies and shove em.
response / report this review -
27 July 2016
I stop everytime I go to Indy .
Her pie's are the best !! I absolutely think she is the best pie maker from a
"store bought" pie !!! She herself, is a very sweet lady. Her apple and cherry are my favorite.
I would definitely recommend her to everyone I know.
HER PIES ARE FANTASTIC !!!
I always see if anyone wants me to pick up any extra for them.
The only problem with her pie shop is,
I WISH IT WERE CLOSER TO ME !!
I just can't say enough about her wonderful
Pie's.
You need to stop and give her a try. It won't be the last time you will stop. .. I promise you that. !!!response / report this review
