I've been going to Renna's for 30 years and it has always been good up until about a year ago. I stop about once a week and I would say at least 8 out of the last 10 times I've stopped I've been disappointed. 2 slice cheese pepperoni To go. Lately it's been either super soggy flimsy crust or not heated enough or too much sauce and today it was too much cheese and it was underdone and not heated enough :(. I might stop again after the holidays but if this continues I'm just going to get pretzels from aunty Ann's. :(
The best Pizza for a good price
Very good food and fast service.
My fiance and I order here on the regular. If you love new York style pizza, this place is for you! I see people complaining about the price.. just so ya know it would be cheaper to buy a full pie than to buy all your slices separately. 😉
Very old school. The place has not changed in 30 years. A great place to grab a few slices quickly.
Love it! I eat there at least once a month. The 🍕 is amazing!
Everyone says this used to be amazing pizza. They also say that it has declined dramatically in quality over the last few years. I'd have to agree. The pizza was bland and overcooked, which made it wildly overpriced. I won't be returning.
I ate here many times when I was younger.
The pizza seemed much more tastier back in the 90's.
The pizza unfortunately was not good at all. The total bill was around $15 for 3 slice's and 2 drinks. Way overpriced and no flavor.
The pizza is setting on a counter top and is simply reheated. Save your money and go elsewhere. Worse pizza in the area.