Poe Brothers' Cafeteria

Location :

1280 Old State Road 67 South, Flagstaff Business Park, Mooresville, IN 46158, USA
Added by Jopie, at 19 February 2017

Add email
Add business description
Add Social Media
Add Products and Services

• Deloris Thompson

  23 November 2017

  Always nice Always clean Always Good and Fresh

  response / report this review
• Brad Knutson

  07 November 2017

  Was taken here by a family member. Our first choice was Gray Brothers Cafeteria, but a local High School had a line going around the building, so we opted for plan B. This was my first experience at a cafeteria style eatery in this area. I wasn't impressed. The meat was either overcooked or dry (according to family members), the Swiss Steak appeared to be hamburger meat. The vegetables were overcooked. The salad greens were wilted. It seemed rather expensive for the quality of the food that we were given. The decor was straight out of the 80s or 90s, very dated and doesn't look like much of anything (including the recipes) have been updated in the last 20-30 years.

  response / report this review
• Anna Marie Liscomb

  17 October 2017

  Great food, lots of choices! Fast service friendly staff big servings, you won't leave hungry guaranteed!

  response / report this review
• Anita Riffel

  27 September 2017

  This has been my favorite place to go out for dinner since I was a small child. My entire family meets here every January 28th for my deceased mothers birthday.

  response / report this review
• Thomas Kilbane

  16 September 2017

  Food was great and staff is friendly. The chicken is the best. Pic is roast beef and a double portion.

  response / report this review
• James Carter

  15 August 2017

  Booked for 20 to 25 room for family .GRT there and find out it was 2 tables for a family. They said who at restuarnt shouldn't book party .and table was next to bunch of holyroller singing and praying POOR SERVICE. Dinner HAM and BEANS half cook . You didn't get TIP from me and I said you should paid me .next time go to gray better food and service

  response / report this review
• Jeff Bryant

  14 July 2017

  I love Poe's Cafeteria. I would much rather eat there than the highly over priced Gray's Cafeteria down the road. The food is great. Pretty waitresses, pleasant atmosphere. Like home.

  response / report this review
• Bradford Morrison

  13 July 2017

  So much more than good food. Big portions. Fun laid back atmosphere. Price way low compared to local overpriced competition. Then another 20% off on Mondays for seniors and vets. Tuesdays 20% off for everyone for Customer appreciation. Free (w meal) Southern Gospel family and quartet Christian music every Wednesday and 2nd Tuesdays. Friendly staff. FUN FUN.

  response / report this review
• Marjorie Perkins

  29 May 2017

  Food wasn't all that good, and it's way over priced

  response / report this review
• Michael Callahan

  22 April 2017

  I like the place although food can be hit or miss. Usually VERY busy.

  response / report this review
• Angela Rutledge

  19 March 2017

  Been going to Poe''s for over 40 years. Our kids, grand and great grandchildren ask to go here with us. Good food wonderful staff.

  response / report this review
• Torry Stiles

  13 March 2017

  Automatic five stars for having gooseberry pie. . Love their "Townhouse" cottage cheese but the recipe is often modified so I can't always be sure what flavor will dominate. This visit they disappointed me with a strawberry-rhubarb pie that was mostly pre-mixed strawberry glaze. The staff is always wonderful especially the floor hostesses.

  response / report this review
• Jeff Mayberry

  26 February 2017

  The best thing about Poe's is it is always nice and quiet, and rarely crowded.

  response / report this review