Sauce was good, but there was nothing New York style about this pie and their "thin" crust would be laughed out of the boroughs. The stromboli was full of ham. Never got that in New York either. I was so excited to find this place online. Sad to say, I will not be returning.
New fave pizza place in town. Love the clam and garlic pizza: never tried clams on pizza (not focaccia pizza) but it was great! Other slices are just as good. Super garlicky, and the foccacia dough was fluffy with a crunchy bottom.
They serve GF pizza. The crust is great. Pizza had too much cheese which made it grease. Missing seasonings to give it pizzazz. Taste is ok.
Beyond disappointed!
I recently moved here from New Jersey and our pizza is just like New York but this taste nothing like back home. The sauce in the cheese pizza had no flavor, plus it was watery! We also had the garlic knots and they had to be the worst we've had they were so dry , no oil or the taste of garlic to them. Garlic knots are supposed to have oil with fresh herbs and garlic on top of each one not some dry bread. I guess its been a long time since they've had New York pizza to try and mimic it. My husband had to be the most disappointed one since he's Italian and he's family owns a pizzeria.
I love this place! Work is right up the street, so I'm always here for lunch. Everything they make is good! Ingredients are always fresh!
Amazing food. Great service. A bunch of delicious pizzas by the slice, we also had the lasagna which was incredible, and the garlic bread alone made it worth the stop! Glad we stumbled across this place!
We went to this place because my son had heard about it. We are a family of 6 with very picky eaters. First of all, we were so impressed with the service!!!! From the owner being so attentive and "no job was too small for him", to the cashier, to everyone in the kitchen. It was like being at home with my mom & dad and family!!!! The food was exceptional! Absolutely delicious pizza and pasta! The ingredients are so fresh and the sauce they made was divine! Thank you for a great experience. We found our go to pizza place!
One of the Best New York Slices in Town Whoever wrote that frozen pizza is better they need to go back from the hole they crawled out
of !!! This Lady knows what she is doing, Great Food as well !!! Great Chef's as well !!!
Just recently discovered Slice of The Pie Pizza and went back for a second time. My wife and I ordered the "All Meat" slice and was disappointed in the flavor and taste profile. Will go back again, but that menu item will not be on our favorite list. We also ordered a "Pinwheel" and were happy with that choice.
Next visit we will try their other slices to keep experimenting with the choices.
Any frozen pizza would be 100 times better than this place.
The best pizza and Subs around!!
The best. Calzones and stromboli yummy. Best italian desert tiramisu Aso very original and my favorite CANOLI