The pizza was really good. Huge variety of toppings and at great price. The staff was really nice and friendly. The only thing, they run a little less on cheese side.
Was the person complimenting the MEDIUM sauce below tongueless? Because it's straight ketchup. Like, literally looks and tastes, and is the consistency of, HEINZ. I called to inquire, asking what the deal was. The lady who answered said there is nothing they could, nor would do, about this issue. She agreed with me that it tastes and smells like tangy ketchup. Yet, she said they would absolutely not be changing a thing, even though I asked "So I can't order wings with my pizza anymore?" she said yes. But to perhaps ask for a mild, and medium mix. MEDIUM is ketchup. I said I could order them dry, with ketchup to dip at home. She said YEAH EXACTLY. Is the honey mustard going to be yellow French's? I worry.
The pizza was okay. Looked like it had been sitting out awhile. I had better just last week-- with no wings. Big caution.
This is the first review I've ever written on Google. Would be willing to change it if they made things right, but their complete lack of sympathy for bad customer experiences is going to make that hard.
Quick, hot. Delicious thin crust with the right amount of toppings. Friendly service.
Panzerotti and pizza are good. Do not order the Caesar salad. They use bacon bits. Gross! Hello! You have bacon all ready to go for the pizza. Charge an extra buck if you must and put real bacon on the salad. The most disgusting salad I've ever had.
Best pizza in St. Thomas! Reasonably priced and food is amazing. Always order panzerottis and wings, all fresh and hot even from delivery. Customer service is always so nice and polite.
in St. Thomas Pizza Tonite WAS so Good. The best in town or comparable BUt WTH happened? First their staffing crew are not polite , well, only if u act the way the command vs actually listening to you. Everytime I order they get the exact same order mess up. HOW ?? The quality has plummeted HUGELY of the Food, Specifically the pizza. it uswd to be thicdk juicy and just the all around PIZZA as we know A PIZZA is,. But Now I get this thin hardly anything to it, dry crap. Making Pizza Pizza look Good. And Pizza Pizza was the record low of quality Pizza. . Idk know if owners now changed. None the less . Sure the guy offered to remedy this on the phone. Delivery me another sauce . By which my DF shrooms would of been too cold. I said but guy. This is a reoccurring problem you guys have on the exact same simple problem that ruins my meal. I said their wont be a third time. i am done with Pizza Tonite. The quality and service isnt worth . The over priced and crap srervice order wrong everytime. The delivery was fast. Which ias nice. But why wouldnt it be.They prolly dont get that much business like they used too. Im DEFINITELY not giving the,m another chance. Done Goodbye Pizza Tonite. You should rename your bussiness. "Order Ain't Right" and others have noticed this about Pizza Tonite, Im sure of it
One of the better places for pizza in St. Thomas. Good selection of apps, the pizza is reasonably priced and tastes great.
Great pizza: you can get any wing sauce substituted as your pizza sauce. Chicken wings are hella dope but a tad pricey. 100% worth it doe.
By far the best things there are the chicken wings and the potato wedges. My favorite wing sauce, Medium. The potato wedges are great too, get a side order of the Medium wing sauce and dip the potato wedges in both the sour cream and the wing sauce. It's absolutely delicious. I know people that will drive an hour just for that alone.