French toast was consumed in its entirety. 4 stars.
Edit: Had dinner too here. Key lime pie was the best in this plane of existence. Tartness was almost overwhelming, but that's what made it. Sweetness is overrated.
Awesome food, great service, and the owner is super friendly and engaged with his customers. Omelet and mahi tacos were both delicious. Highly recommend!
Our dinner was beautifully presented, hot and delicious. The roasted pine nuts were a surprise but the flavor and texture only enhanced the meal. Our waiter suggested a great wine too. Have eaten here before and each time we have enjoyed a great dining experience.
Great dining experience with great food expertly prepared. Dining indoors and outdoors are both pleasurable in this quaint establishment in old Key West.
Seriously best meal of the entire trip. The staff was extremely accommodating and went above and beyond to ensure we had a terrific meal. Keep up the great work!
Simply outstanding! The tomato soup and fried chicken are out of this world good. The shrimp and grits is also amazing. Great service too. Highly recommended!
After trying about a dozen brunch places on the island, this one is the best. Staff is ultra friendly. The owner and hostess are out there hustling for customers. Even when there's a wait (which is often) they're walking up to you every 5-10 minutes to update you when your table will be ready. You never feel "forgotten" even when there's a long wait. Food is delicious. Salmon egg benedict is tasty and light but will still keep you full for a while. Prices are pretty good.
Came here for brunch on Sunday, everything was beyond amazing. Top-notch food and service. Hostess was very nice and sat us quickly even though they were packed. Our server, Ariel, was one of the best we've ever had. He was friendly and attentive without being overbearing. My only complaint is they don't open a Sarabeths closer to Hypoluxo, FL so we can come more often. Ariel, thank you so much!
The serving staff were very friendly and attentive, however I found it a bit pricy and I wasn't "wowed" by the food. It was good, but not my "death row meal".
Incredible food, incredible atmosphere, incredible staff. Just a joy to come here. It's my new favorite place in Key West.
Shared a spinach and goat cheese omelet, a pumpkin waffle and a side of duck bacon (had to try that!) everything was very very good! Ate alfresco on the porch, great Key West ambiance.
Great food! I had the Goldie Lox and it was fabulous.
2 things that I didn't like so much:
Our waitress was not very friendly and a little inattentive.
The portions were kinda small.
I would come back here though just for the amazing food and hope for better service.
My wife and I were there for our anniversary two weeks ago and decided to drop in for dinner as we remembered having visited this place a few years back. It turned out to be quite the great dinner experience. Actually, it may have been one of the best dinners we have had in Key Westever. Not only was every part of the meal delicious, the service was absolutely the best. One can immediately see that the employees take pride in what they do. We were so pleased that we decided to have breakfast here the next morning. Again, it was perfect in every way. I don't remember the manager's name but he was one of the best people I have ever dealt with anywhere. Thanks Sarabeth's. See you soon.