About
Location :
Added by Jopie, at 05 December 2016
Opening Hours
- Monday 4:00 – 11:00 PM
- Tuesday 4:00 – 11:00 PM
- Wednesday 4:00 – 11:00 PM
- Thursday 4:00 – 11:00 PM
- Friday 4:00 – 11:00 PM
- Saturday 4:00 – 11:00 PM
- Sunday 4:00 – 11:00 PM
Gallery
Add missing information
12 Reviews
-
16 December 2017
Incredibly good food with proper portions. All three of us loved what we had and we look forward to visiting again next year. The service was exceptional. The outdoor seating was lovely and lit beautifully.
response / report this review -
12 December 2017
Excellent meat lasagna. Speed of service was great. They are no longer open for lunch. Hours are 4P to 11P. I will definitely be back!
response / report this review -
24 September 2017
Very good food!!! Will accommodate for your needs. Attentive staff!! Wonderful outdoor dining as well as small intimate indoor dining. Loved the birds too!!! If you want they will sit on your shoulder.!!!
response / report this review -
26 August 2017
Came here as part of a very large group of 22 people. Food and service was excellent. They were very warm, welcome and accommodating. Would absolutely go here again on our next visit to Key West!
response / report this review -
16 August 2017
Possibly the best place I've eaten while in Key West! Right off Duval Street, so it was really easy to find, but there was no street noise from Duval, which is hard to find. Wonderfully fast seating from the host, and our waiter was excited to interact with us, and he really knew the menu. Our food was incredible and, keep room for dessert, because the cannoli is absolutely phenomenal!
response / report this review -
06 August 2017
We showed up at 11:20 PM on a Saturday night when they close at 11. Not only did they keep the restaurant open for us, we were treated like we were the first customers of the day. Full wait staff catered to us and the owners son made our dinners. The food was fascistic and the service was outstanding.. The atmosphere and ambience are charming and classy!. Highly recommend New York Pasta Garden!!
response / report this review -
01 August 2017
Have been to the Pasta Garden twice. Once for a wedding and today for a casual dinner. It is hard to rate a restaurant when it cooks for a large group. But today told me what kind of food to expect. Well my chicken parm was spot on. The other guests had fillets, pasta and grouper. There were no complaints. Excellent food and perfectly cooked. The menu is very diverse. There is something for everyone.
response / report this review -
21 April 2017
Ran into some people from new jersey having lunch one day. They mentioned there was only 1 real Italian restaurant on the island and went on to tell us about this place. I asked about the menu. They said the calamari was amazing as was the veal. My 2 favorites. We went the following night. It was exactly as advertised. Not only was the food amazing but the atmosphere was with the parrots and the owner was equally as good! A must visit in my opinion
response / report this review -
17 March 2017
Absolutely great in every regard. All food items were prepared perfectly, not overpriced considering the quality and portion size, and the best part was the service. Andre was attentive but not hovering and took care of our entire party of 6 effortlessly. This will be the first place I revisit in Key West and if you have any doubts it is the best food in town you need to go and prove it to yourself.
response / report this review -
09 March 2017
Class. This is an impressive restaurant (with white table cloths). Located in Duval Square where there's parking! Food was authentic and timed to the table properly. Staff was perfect and professional. This was our least expensive meal here in Key West. There are two other equal restaurants right next door. You can talk to the birds there.
response / report this review -
08 February 2017
Very cool spot with seating available in this treetop-covered Alley between two strips of buildings. You can't see it from Duvall Street, but you can definitely smell it! Best Italian I've ever had. Seriously! Big portions and reasonable prices.
response / report this review -
12 December 2016
This delightful Italian eatery's lovely ambiance is only outdone by its delicious food. The portions are hearty, the flavors are robust, and the staff is pleasant. The experience is capped off by the resident parrots that will accompany you for dinner either from their nearby perch or at your table. Romantic, family and pet friendly, this is a must-stop for any visitor. We will definitely be back on our next trip to Key West, if not while we are here in this one.
response / report this review
