About
Location :
Added by Jopie, at 22 December 2016
Opening Hours
- Monday 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Tuesday 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Wednesday 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Thursday 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Friday 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Saturday 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Sunday 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Gallery
Add missing information
14 Reviews
-
24 November 2017
Just rating the pie itself because we didn’t buy it in their store. Amigos was serving their pie and we loved it.
response / report this review -
21 November 2017
One of the best pie places in the island. Loving the key lime pie flavored everything.
response / report this review -
24 October 2017
The Key Lime Icecream is heavenly. They pile it into a freshly baked waffle cone that is to die for! The staff is incredibly welcoming, and kind. Don't leave the Keys without stopping by!!
response / report this review -
23 October 2017
Really good key lime pie and the staff is very friendly. Take out or eat in. Nice selection of candies too.
response / report this review -
14 September 2017
Great place freshly baked pie amongst other sweets they even make there own drink which is delicious
response / report this review -
10 September 2017
Very good key lime pie. A good as any I ate all week long.
response / report this review -
08 September 2017
A slice of heaven in your mouth. $40 to ship to NY is totally worth it! Who said money can't buy happiness?
response / report this review -
02 August 2017
The best pie on the island. The lime drink is incredible, but you only get a few sips before the rest is ice. The decor is clean and the staff is helpful and courteous.
response / report this review -
31 July 2017
Key West Lime Pie is Sweet Pete's but it's nothing like the one in Jacksonville Florida or the one you have seen on the Profit Show much much much smaller there's no tours but you can buy candy..pies.. cookies..and ice cream not a lot of selections. Mostly about key lime so that's why if you Google Sweet Pete's Key Lime Company comes up and nothing about Sweet Pete's.. was disappointed about that but Key West was fun..
response / report this review -
16 April 2017
I would recommend the extra tart unless you like your pie very sweet. The pie is ok.
response / report this review -
01 April 2017
Nice place and the staff was pretty awesome. I was like a kid in a candy store wanting to try everything. Was offered samplesLoved the different salsas that were displayed. Can't wait to return!
response / report this review -
22 March 2017
The best key lime pie in the Keys and I've tried most of all. It's worth the wait to get to one of their several locations. This location allows you to test taste assorted key lime cookies, too!!
response / report this review -
12 January 2017
Much better key lime pie than what served in other restaurants IMO, without a (outrageous) heap of cream or meringue - you're eating key lime pie, or just cream or merengue?. We opted for extra tart, which is very good! Probably slightly slightly too tart result in a bit of disconnection of the favor, but we still very much like it! It's still sweet, smooth, and very refreshing. Probably not as good as "Better Than Sex"'s Kinky Key West Cream Pie, but how can I complain at less than half the price? Love it!
response / report this review -
29 December 2016
Best Key Lime pie in my opinion. I have tried them all and this place by far does it the best. Always quick service and fresh pie for a great price.
response / report this review
