Love Jeremiah’s! Food is good and the service is fast and efficient.
What the hell happened to this place?? In the past I've given it a 5 star rating & thought they had the best wings in Rochester.
But I went there recently and the wings were only fair not very warm & not very meaty most were scrawny wings with only 2 drumsticks in the entire order for 3 people!
On top of that, we rarely saw our waitress, even though we needed things throughout our meal. She couldn't have cared less about us until the magic "tip time" came.
I guess I should've known things had really gone downhill there when I called on a Friday evening & was told that I didn't need a reservation. Sure enough, when we got there we were greeted by tons of empty tables at 8pm! In retrospect, we should've just turned around & left at that point.
I guarantee I won't be going back there again.
What a shame, it used to be a great place for draft beers, wings, fish frys & pub food.
Used to be billed "As comfortable as your favorite jeans" but it's anything but these days. I went on a trivia night, which was a mistake because I wanted to watch the Yankees. Beer was pricey, bartender seemed unaware of what was on tap. I asked one bartender what was on the genesee tap and he lost interest in answering me so I had to flag down the second bartender. Generally smells like a few labatts have been spilled on the floor. Food continues to climb in cost so I don't eat here anymore. Used to go here to watch sports and meet family for fish fry, not anymore. I've heard it's been sold a few times, maybe a committed owner could push down the drunk bar vibe but I doubt anyone will as long as people keep buying pricey beer and food.
Great food always an amazing variety n the menu. Wings.yes this is without question one of the major players in the best wings in Rochester game. Tons of drink specials for happy hour and lots of TV's to watch the game.
Great wings and amazing black bean burgers!!!!! Cannot stress enough how good the black bean burger is. I went to jail with a few of there employees and did some work for another. Good dudes.
The food was OK. Unfortunately the appetizers, soup and dinner came out at the same time so by the time you had your soup the dinner was cold. Warming up food negates the original flavor - quite disappointing service.
Best wings in Rochester. Awesome beer selection. Always have a good time there. Wraps are solid. Quick service
Service was great. Loved the food, and yes wings are as good as everyone says
Not a fan. They have redone their menu in the past few years and expanded but not my sort of joint. If you like loud settings with a lot of monitors to watch sports on, game on. Otherwise go elsewhere. The wings aren't as awesome as people make them out to be and the rest of the menu seems uninspired. Good for a quick beer but that's about it.
The food is remarkably good for a bar/pub. Jeremiah's is definitely one of my most favorite restaurants in Rochester. I've tried almost every item on the menu and I like them all. They're known for their wings (I prefer the Bee Sting sauce) but I don't think they get enough credit for the rest of their menu. The Buffalo Chicken wrap is great, their Twisted Mac and Cheese is amazing, and the lobster bisque and their clam chowder (both on Fridays) are incredible.
They have a HUGE beer selection (on tap), and the place itself had plenty of seating - especially for large groups.
I'd recommend this Rochester staple to anyone.
One of my favorite places to go for dinner when I'm in town. I've had a variety of things on the menu and I've never been disappointed. The wings are amazing, so are their sandwiches, and other dinner entrees.
For me it's a quick walk there, and a nice staple. It's a sports bar, so it's what you'd want out of a sports bar. Wings are always good, and everyone knows that, since they've been voted best wings in Rochester for like a billion years. All the other food I've had has been good also. The brie burger was sloppy, tasty and different. Service has always been really good. It can get a little crowed though, especially during football. Oh one other thing that i didn't expect, their bloody Mary's are quite delicious. I've had bloodys every place I go, and theirs is well above the average sports bar, and actually above a lot of other places who actually advertise bloody Marys.