• Delete
  • Edit

About

Gray Brothers Cafeteria is a restaurant, located at 555 S Indiana St, Mooresville, IN 46158, USA. They can be contacted via phone at +1 317-831-7234, visit their website www.graybroscafe.com for more detailed information.

Location :
555 S Indiana St, Mooresville, IN 46158, USA
Added by Jopie, at 07 February 2017

Opening Hours

  • Monday 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
  • Tuesday 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
  • Wednesday 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
  • Thursday 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
  • Friday 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
  • Saturday 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
  • Sunday 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM

Add missing information

Add email
Add business description
Add Social Media
Add Products and Services

15 Reviews

  • Calla Dain
    22 December 2017

    Half empty restaurant. I have a party of 15 coming, half of them already here, and a waitress hassles me and my disabled mother sitting at two large tables that will accommodate my party, that we can't "reserve seats." I've been going there all my life and have never had that issue. Good food though.

    response / report this review
  • Chad McClellan
    17 December 2017

    Sometimes there's long lines to eat at this cafeteria style restaurant, but it worth it. The food is very good, average sized portions, a bit expensive, but a nice place to go eat on various occasions.

    Reminds me of the great cafeterias of when I was a child traveling with my parents, back when cafeterias served very good food. Well, this place did and still does serve very good food! Come try it and see for yourself.

    response / report this review
  • Penny Crawley
    08 December 2017

    Good restaurant for cafeteria food, veggies & great pies! Know for fried chicken, etc. Prices have raised this fall. Still a good value when wanting something other than bar food & wings.

    response / report this review
  • Steven Willett
    15 November 2017

    Don't know what has happened but on my last visit, and it may be my last, I got carry-out, trusting that the same delicious food would be served only to find that Friday's Mac and Cheese was more like left from Wednesday before, crunchy hard. The Harvard beets ( three of them) we old, oversized and the was no sauce. Not fit to eat. Then the chicken wasn't Gray's Famous #2 in the state fried chicken. What is Going On?! They got one star because there is no lower option.

    response / report this review
  • Rebeca Perrone
    15 November 2017

    Great home style lunch! More than than enough options to satisfy any appetite and taste. Plenty of room in the dining room but I can definitely see it getting packed after church let's out. Overall great experience, if I'm ever in the area I'd try it out again!

    response / report this review
  • Hoosier Jonny
    09 October 2017

    Excellent meal and very good service. Waitresses were very good at taking care of drinks and the workers on the line made things move along smoothly. Also saw a great (and rare) act, a gentleman working the food line thanked the military veterans for their service. Great place and worth the stop!

    response / report this review
  • Dan Ripberger
    02 October 2017

    Love it great place to eat. It's just good old fashioned food done right

    response / report this review
  • Cheryl Atchley
    11 September 2017

    Food was delicious, staff is very helpful and polite. They have a nice little gift shop. Plenty of parking space. Very clean. Worth the drive north.

    response / report this review
  • Rita Crouse
    01 September 2017

    Very disappointed, again, third time since new owners, kept hoping would go back to the way it used to be. Doesn't deserve to be called "Gray's". Tough, chewy, baked chicken, hummingbird cake not OG recipe, stuffing was sweet (not in a good way). Yuck. Not old fashioned cooking anymore. Very sad day. Plus, the prices are 25% more. Not a good business strategy. Will not be back, ever. This was a Thursday at 3p. :'(

    response / report this review
  • CADEN MONTGOMERY
    09 August 2017

    Friendly staff and rustic atmosphere. Cafeteria style. Great pies. Little $$$ but the food is dang near worth the price. Super freaking busy on holidays

    response / report this review
  • Tim Williams
    24 April 2017

    Excellent Food. Good Service. Anxious to correct any problem. great choice.

    response / report this review
  • Scott Wolff
    04 April 2017

    Terrific food always! A great place for reliable comfort food that continually provides consistent results. Worth the money you pay for the meal. A great place for lunch, dinner or coffe and dessert.

    response / report this review
  • J Christy Wareham
    02 April 2017

    Nowhere I've ever been have I found genuine comfort food so carefully prepared to satisfy the stomach and the soul. Me, I go for the meatloaf, because nothing says home like a generous slab of meatloaf pretty darn close to what grandma made in her Central Michigan farm kitchen. But try anything you think you'll like, and I dare you to go out the door without a grin on your face.

    response / report this review
  • A Leap
    08 March 2017

    Tueday evening for 5pm dinner. We sailed through the line. The food all looked very tasty. We had chicken livers, and salmon patties. Wow!!! The sides were all gorgeous and perfectly seasoned. The green beans were very notable along with the scalloped potatoes. Everyone had muffins: blueberry, chocolate chunk and cranberry were all scrumptious! The service was spot on and not too intrusive. It had been years since I ate at Gray Bros and other than the distance, I could not think of why! An all around enjoyable and entirely tasty experience.

    response / report this review
  • Tay Aoki
    14 February 2017

    Always a delight to eat here. I love their meatloaf; it doesn't feel too dough-y like many restaurants, thickly cut, and meaty. Fried chickens are good too, thin, but crispy crust. Juicy meat and cooked through. Pies of our selection is strawberry shortcake pie (I think they called it that? but ton of cream. So it's like a strawberry with whip cream) and pecan pie. We usually like their mac 'n' cheese but cheese was disappointing this time. Little granulated? Stuffing was bland and bread-y once so I've been avoiding.

    response / report this review

Rate & Write Reviews