About
Location :
Added by Jopie, at 08 February 2017
Opening Hours
- Monday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Tuesday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Wednesday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Thursday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Friday 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Saturday 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Sunday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Gallery
Add missing information
14 Reviews
-
14 December 2017
Great Seafood served here :-) The owner and I talked for a long time. If you're Military or Retired Military, let them know to get a discount here.
response / report this review -
02 December 2017
A great family owned spot. However my lobster was over cooked which always makes me so sad. Beware peeps like to squat on the very limited seating while they order so you may have to eat your food on your lap.
response / report this review -
21 November 2017
Great selection of local seafood to take home to cook. Their prepared dishes are excellent and there is a cute little outdoor eating area.
response / report this review -
20 November 2017
This place is easy to miss if you're not looking for it, they have a decent selection of seafood sandwiches, we tried the shrimp taco, yellow tail sandwich, lobster roll and crab cake sandwich. My personal favorite was the shrimp taco, the sauce on it is amazing!
All plates come with a fresh and taste coleslaw salad and a plantain chips bag.
They only have outdoor seating (about 4 tables) and no highchairs .response / report this review -
03 October 2017
The best place to have fresh and delicious local seafood. Every trip to Key West is a must visit!!
response / report this review -
05 September 2017
Great lobster. Staff very helpful packing up our lobster for our trip home.
response / report this review -
03 August 2017
Fresh seafood for you to take home and make an amazing meal. Or dine at there cozy restaurant and eat street side. YUM
response / report this review -
30 July 2017
Been to KW several times but stumbled upon Eaton Street Seafood Market for the first time. Amazing quality, super nice staff, yummy food.
A new "have to go" spot for me.response / report this review -
19 July 2017
Oh my! What a great fish store! We found you on google and drove here from a great day at the beach! We wanted fresh fish to BBQ in foil with some butter and seasoning!
The young lady behind the counter gave us 3 great options. The golden tile was fresh and she highly recommended it! It was amazing! She also found a dry seasoning that they make!
Grabbed a key lime pie for dessert to make our meal and experience here perfect!
The fish turned out perfect!
I highly recommend this place!
Thank you from Washington state!response / report this review -
14 April 2017
Choose one of the fish on offer that day, they will grill/blacken it and put it in a sandwich with salad. Eat at one of the few table outside or take out and sit at the harbour with your loot. A really fresh, tasty, and filling bite to eat. Great quality produce. Highly recommend.
response / report this review -
21 March 2017
You will need to spend a lot of money to get filled up. However, the lobster roll was very good, just small for $20. I would probably need to spend $50 or so to get enough to eat. The outdoor seating atmosphere was simple and enjoyable.
response / report this review -
15 March 2017
Go here all the time! The freshest seafood you can get in town! Lobster roll is our favorite but everything else is amazing to! You can eat here outside or take stuff to go! Don't forget to grab some fish dip while you're there, you'll never want it again from anywhere else! The staff is super friendly and can als recommend ways to cook things if you decide to just purchase stuff to make yourself!!
response / report this review -
25 February 2017
This place was wonderful. The staff was kind and our orders arrived in a timely manner. My food was delicious. I highly recommend the fish tacos. I also purchased smoked fish dip and key lime pie. My tummy was very happy. A great restaurant to eat at. I would definitely eat there again.
response / report this review -
15 February 2017
Don't turn around until you try it!! The place is small but it's all about the quality. We tried lobster roll, the difference is they gave you all lobster meat not like the other places using lots of fillers. Same as crab cake. We also bought a sashimi quality of tuna and had them prepare on site as Ahi tuna. It's delicious. They also grilled scallops as the way we liked. The prices are reasonable.
The owner is very friendly. We enjoyed chatting with him. Definitely will go back while in Key West next time.response / report this review
