• Delete
  • Edit

About

South Fin Grill is a restaurant, located at 300 Father Capodanno Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA. They can be contacted via phone at +1 718-447-7679, visit their website www.southfingrill.com for more detailed information.

Location :
300 Father Capodanno Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA
Added by Jopie, at 29 December 2016

Add missing information

Add email
Add business description
Add Social Media
Add Products and Services

11 Reviews

  • Dennis Janezic
    08 December 2017

    Went there for a retirement party. The staff couldn't have been nicer. Good food, very nice venue. Nina the bartender was super nice and sweet

    response / report this review
  • Anthony Vincenzo
    26 September 2017

    Went for Happy Hour on Thursday night. Had a great time - appetizers were excellent, although one was made with the wrong ingredients; the bartender Crystal was extremely nice, funny, professional and helpful, and replaced the wrong appetizer immediately. Then decided to go on Friday night again - big disappointment. We were told that only TWO wines were the "happy hour" choice - which we didn't encounter on Thursday night, where we tried several wines and weren't told they weren't on the 'happy hour' menu. We tried explaining this to the bartender, but she said the Thursday night bartender must have been wrong ok, whatever. I have never encountered a happy hour with only two choices - not even half-price drinks are offered, apparently. So, what's so 'happy' about that? In any event, I am giving it one more shot. If 'happy hour' really does consist of only two choices of wine and nothing else, I can be 'happy' at home for less money and better wine.

    response / report this review
  • JT Q
    06 September 2017

    Had a 5:30pm reservation for 7 people. When we showed up at 5:30pm we had to wait while they scrambled to push tables together and the waitress finished getting dressed in to her uniform in front of us.Very slow service and completely overpriced. At one point a bus boy was walking around the dining room with 2 plates of food asking tables if it was theirs, he went to 4 wrong tables before finding the right one. Some food was OK, some food was disgusting, some food came to the table wrong. The outside chairs had seagull feathers smashed into the cushions. Find a different place.

    response / report this review
  • Adriana Basile
    20 August 2017

    Where do I start. We get there and are told there is an hour wait for outside seating and half an hour for indoors. That's find because what I nice night to d out by the water. So we get a drink at the bar. First red flag of the night, we order 2 drinks and I see in the menu the price is $11 per drink but still asks the bartender how much. She says she doesn't know the price and has to see. One drink in we decide to continue waiting where there are seat. We're told we can sit there but need to order our drinks from the waitress of that area. So we do we sit, get drink menus from her but she never comes back to get our orsde!!! So over half an hour and still no call.from the hostess station my sister goes to check. The new girl there tells her it's a 25 minute wait. Huh what confusion as my sis starts walking away annoyed to manager runs and gets her and says we can be seated. To our amazement there are so many open tables inside!!! So why the hell the wait!! We are seated and the host leaves menus. Over 15 minutes from that there is no waiter, nobody checking in on us for food so we grab the busboy and ask him who out waiter is. A few minutes later some confused employee comes to us saying he isn't our waiter but can help us. We order 2 appetizers. Need finally comes our.. well the 2 biscuits. Ate those fast because we are now starving. Oysters arrive and instead of taking the empty plate from the bread the food runner moves that plate in front of my sister and leaves. We need to ask for dishes.. the other waiter comes back once are done with the oysters to take our entree order. We ask about the second appetizer. Oh surprise he forgot so he went to "check on the order. Finally the second app came. Then the entree but the waiter never again checked on us. My sister asked the busboy for salt and lemon.. neither which were brought to the table. Finally waiter came back with the table with the dessert menu. We told him the disappointment in service, we didn't want dessert just the check. Instead of apologizing or addressing it with us he just disregarded us and turned and dropped the menus at the next table. Pretty much threw the book with the receipt on our table. Oh and by the way we both ordered different tuna dishes.. yet it looked and cooked the same only mine had some rice in the middle. Never going back!!

    response / report this review
  • Ladi Dre
    09 August 2017

    Amazing view, great ambiance. App was delicious!!! For being one of 4 tables on a Tuesday night service was super slow. Kept having to ask for water. For the prices one would expect bread on the table
    Asked for a rare steak, it was well done; sent it back - came back med + extra salty asparagus and mashed - they sure showed me!
    The lady behind us after not being greeted by a server for 10 min had to ask for service.
    What they lack in service, the view and ambiance makes up for. The app totally overshadowed the entree.
    I would actually go back. Considering fish is their forte I'll give it another go

    response / report this review
  • Mike Campbell
    16 July 2017

    The food tastes good as long as they can bring you what you actually order. Table of four ordered different items and three received the same thing. We were there for over an hour and a half. Had to ask for the check as no one else did. The bill was incorrect as it was split and the wrong things were on the wrong bill. I had to bring the checks to them as they weren't coming to get them. Then only one came back. Had to ask for the other one. Terrible place.

    response / report this review
  • M. A.
    03 June 2017

    The good first, the food and ambiance, the waiter seemed like a very nice guy.
    The bad, waited over 1hr for appetizers, we weren't the only table either that waited that long. Finally were we told that they will expedite our apps (another 30 mins). Food tasted good, entree's were good and served in a timely manner. For the prices..service has to be better!!!

    response / report this review
  • Timothy Alexander
    21 May 2017

    I was there for a large family event. Those at my table received their steaks cold and not cooked to order. When desert was served, they forgot about half the table. It was a bad experience all the way around.

    response / report this review
  • Alex S.
    18 May 2017

    Where do I begin? My steak took over an hour to come out and when it did, it was very undercooked and my girlfriends shrimp and linguini pasta was nothing to write home about. The service was unrealistically slow for a Wednesday evening (which turned into a much longer experience than I wanted, almost 3 hours for a simple dinner.) The only reason it's getting 1 star, aside from the fact that I'm not able to give it 0 stars, is that the calamari appetizer was actually really good. I was expecting a much nicer experience compared to what I got. Woe is me

    response / report this review
  • Gary H
    08 May 2017

    Here for a party and had a fantastic time with friends. Food was great, drinks were good but could have used a second bartender. Would recommend for any occasion or just to hang with friends.

    response / report this review
  • Jeb Starr
    05 January 2017

    We were here on December 8th, 2016. If you plan to go here, it is very important for you to consider going elsewhere. I have an unwholesome experience at South Fin's valet parking service. The owner of that valet parking company promised to give back my money (which is not a small amount).I began to call him after the incident. He promised to see the videos on what really had happened. I called him again yesterday, January 4, and said that he will call me back when he can. I don't believe it would take a month only to see videos like that. His usual responses are: "I will call you back," "I'm gonna see the videos first.." He simply had no plans to give the money back. That gave me this decision to leave this review on South Fin because that valet parking company is part of their service.

    response / report this review

Rate & Write Reviews