Name: Secret Sandwich Society
Address: 103 Keller Ave, Fayetteville, WV 25840, USA, US
Telephone: +1 304-574-4777

Secret Sandwich Society is a meal takeaway, located at 103 Keller Ave, Fayetteville, WV 25840, USA. They can be contacted via phone at +1 304-574-4777, visit their website www.secretsandwichsociety.com for more detailed information.

Location :

103 Keller Ave, Fayetteville, WV 25840, USA

Contacts :

Added by Jopie, at 29 August 2016

Add email
Add business description
Add Social Media
Add Products and Services

Rachel McOwen

29 May 2021

I was confused why it was closed because their website made it seem like they are open, but the building is literally gone. There’s no restaurant left. It was great, but I don’t know where it went!
Erik Gavin

28 May 2021

Was a very great sandwich restaurant. I heard a fire happened last year but they are planning to build and reopen there.
Dana Rukse

14 November 2020

Awesome place for a meal. If you're passing by, definitely stop in for a bite. Google would not ad my edit. They had a devastating fire a week ago and are closed at the moment.
Joshua Elswick

19 September 2020

My favorite place to eat in the state of WV
Angela Scott

05 September 2020

Pimento cheese fries and Ace pineapple cider 🖤🖤🖤
Mike Keffer

29 November 2017

Who knows? We were turned away after being told of a possible 30 to 40 minute wait with six empty tables??? When I asked where we to wait I was told to go to the park? I heard great things but I won't try them for a while now. Poor customer service from a small place in a small town in the middle of nowhere. They could have used our business.

We went upstairs initially, it was empty. We were referred to the downstairs entrance where there were about 8 people waiting, not 20. Thanks for making our decision easy!
Daniel Smelker-Cheeseman

29 November 2017

This was the most amazing gourmet sandwich shop I had ever been to In My Life. We just happen to come cross it while we are on a road trip. it's been a year and half now and I still think about my sandwich. Thank you all for wonderful sandwich and a memorable experience.
Kiliaen Anderson

25 November 2017

Best burger I've ever had. They make their own ketchup! Food is fresh. Highly recommend.
Nicolle DeLiso

20 November 2017

Outstanding little shop with delicious gourmet sandwiches. I had the Tate, and it was jammed full of pork. I don't care for mayonnaise, but the rosemary mayo was so tasty and gave the meat a great flavor. The homemade chips were nice and crispy and the onion dip was excellent. The service was on point with friendly and attentive staff. Can't wait to be driving through and stop again.
Mike Jones

22 August 2017

WoW totally blown away!!! Wonderful, Amazing, out of this world.
Put this on your bucket list. I can't wait to go back. If there was a Secret Sandwich Society in Charleston, WV I would never buy groceries again
My taste buds are screaming for more!!!!!
Don Johnson

10 August 2017

One of my favorite specialty sandwich shops anywhere! Good selection of craft beer as well. I've tried several of the sandwiches (Washington, Jefferson, McKinley, Eisenhower, Fillmore) loved them all. The place is usually full during peak times, but the wait has never been too long. Well worth a look if you're traveling on 19.
Zach Locks

29 July 2017

Amazing food that is unique and locally owned. I highly recommend anyone visiting or passing through this area stop at this place. They are usually very busy so if you're in a hurry call ahead and get it to go. There's a small park next to it with picnic tables you can eat your take out at. I would also recommend getting an order of loaded cheese fries too.
Meredith Foster

26 July 2017

DELICIOUS! They are always packed but they have a bar upstairs so it's no trouble to wait for a table. There is not one item on the menu I wouldn't recommend. Everything is delicious. I love the pimento cheese fries and the Washington. They have a wide variety of beers and hard ciders. The staff is always friendly and service is relatively quick. This place is just great.
Jodi Heath

03 July 2017

Food is delicious and priced right! Upstairs bar offers a place to wait for your table while grabbing a drink- great variety of beers and fun seating options. Kennedy sandwich was a huge hit with our group but everyone was pleased with their choices. We also enjoyed the craft beer selection. Sandwiches are named after presidents making for a fun twist on the menu. Outdoor seating provided a nice atmosphere in a quiet small town. Pimento cheese fries were a big hit as an appetizer with our group.
Gilbert Smith III

05 January 2017

Very interesting place with some unique combos you won't find elsewhere. The pimento cheese fries are great! If you're in Fayetteville for a visit, definitely stop by and try it.
Rick Starsick

29 November 2016

If you want a sandwich that you have never had before, this is the place. A very cool, trendy hipster sort of venue, this restaurant exudes the beatnik culture. Hard to believe you would find it in one of the smallest towns in the state. I recommend if you're driving on Route 19 back to North or South Carolina, make a stop here you won't regret it.
Christina Hornack

26 November 2016

This was sooo good! We have been driving by for a while on our way to visit family and we finally stopped. I am so glad we did! The food is fantastic, the service very responsive, and the atmosphere is just what you'd want for a sandwich and a pint. Seriously - stop here. It's worth the wait!
Carol Perry

20 November 2016

Waiter never came back to see if our food was satisfactory after he recommended that certain sandwich. I am not a fan of horseradish which I told him & he assured me it was mixed with mayo & would be fine. I actually had to use napkins to remove as much of the horseradish as possible to even eat the sandwich. We were never offered refills on drinks either.
Stephen Ryan

05 September 2016

We decided to take a joyride on the motorcycle on the spur of the moment. I knew the general area that I wanted to head for but didn't know where to grab a late lunch once we got there. Wanting to avoid the typical fast food fare, SSS turned up in a Google search. They were quite busy when we got there resulting in about an hour wait for a table. We spent the time resting from our 2 and 1/2 hour ride upstairs enjoying some cold drinks and then sitting in the small park area next door.

Once we got the text that our table was ready we headed straight inside. We already knew what we wanted to order (pull up their menu on the website while you wait). Our appetizer came quickly (seasoned fries w/ pimento cheese sauce, jalapenos and bacon! OMG!!!) and our sandwiches soon after. We sat on the deck enjoying the late afternoon breeze and had a fantastic meal. The staff was prompt and courteous and our meal was a delicious bargain.

Only thing that kept me from giving 5 stars was the wait time.not sure how this could be fixed, though, given the small dining area and the number of folks trying to get in on a Sunday afternoon. We are definitely fans, though, and will be returning soon with friends in tow!