This restaurant is one of the best Italian restaurants around. I would say in a 100 mile radius from Elmira. When-ever we travel to Geneva N.Y., or going through, we make it a point to not eat, so we can have dinner here.
My husband and I are not from the area, visiting wine country for our anniversary and staying at a nearby hotel. Googled restaurants and decided on his one. The food was excellent! The appetizers were excellent. The staff was attentive. I am from Italian herit age and the veal picatta was one of the very best I have ever had. 4 stars because it took a lot longer to get our food than expected from any restaurant on a Monday night. We would go again though.
Another great meal at Cosentino's! Everyone had a great time. Service was outstanding!
Great food, good prices and large potions. Very nice employees. Will definitely stop by again when visiting the area.
Waitress was good, salad was great. Mushroom appetizer was good. Others entrees were ok
My special gnocchi was ok but the sauce tasted sour or had sage or something in it
The waitress provided me with an alternate dish immediately and did not charge for the first.
A great experience from start to finish the staff is very attentive the food was delicious and fairly evenly priced. Would recommend this to anyone looking for a formal or informal meal
Portions are huge, so be prepared to take doggy bags home or regret wasting food. Food is of reasonably good quality. Mostly older (senior citizens) crowd, but good ambiance.
Amazing food, friendly staff, but only downside was portion size. I definitely know what I'm gonna have for dinner tomorrow!
The overall appearance of the dining area has taken a new look from my last visit. Renovation was done beautifully. The service was prompt and courteous and the food was very good. I will definitely go again.
I went there in September and was charmed and impressed, came through last night and was totally disapponted. The service was mediocre at best and the quality of food (I ordred the samethings)has definitely was not the same. They should have warned me before I ordered my second drink that they were closednever felt so rushed and unwelcome anywhere.
Such a wonderful place the food is pleasing to the eyes and tastebuds. The fibes are so wonderful so family friendly
Had dinner there. Food was good. Service was friendly and prompt.
Best veal parmigiana and angel hair pasta. They have Peroni on tap! Dessert was pumpkin cheesecake. Outta this world. You must eat here. Same family that owned Nana's.
I visited the finger lakes region for a vacation. I was driving around Geneva one night looking for dinner to which there are not many options in the area. This little italian place was pleasantly very good. I am from Boston and used to great fine dining. But this place was a great family owned simple italian food.