I loved this place. Carmine’s was pretty good food is good servers are nice. It’s just Carmine’s has massive portions. Our waiter was on top of everything and was really quick. People here were really friendly. I would defiantly recommend this place to other people
While the Staff were gracious and friendly the food was vile.Salad was wilty lettuce with too much dressing.We ordered Zuppa de mussels that you had to spit out of your mouth and the filletto de pomodoro was tateless.We canceled the remainder of our order and got the check and left.Dont waste your time
Extremely friendly staff and rustic place for Italian dining! Portions are humongous and the food is great.
I certainly recommend this restaurant.
Good food that packed a bunch. Ordered bread pudding for dessert, it’s a good size
Massive portions but worth every penny! One plate will be enough for a family of 3 or 4. Staff genuinely helpful and sincere. Be sure to reserve in advance.
Absolutely horrific. The food was terrible, portions were massive, and three members of our party of four got food poisoning after the fact. Not only that, but we saw two kids on two separate occasions throw up as a result as well.
Italian atmosphere and a pleasant family meal. Meatballs are good. Titanic dessert will sink your diet.
Always have good service and great food. Enough for next day leftovers. We go every year since 2007.
This is the only place I would give 5 stars and even more, if possible. Beware that the portions are beyond huge, if you are two people. Carlette, our waitress was really cordial and super attentive. Chicken parmesan was great, and the Carmine's salad was huge. All the restaurant in Paradise island are super expensive and a rip off. Do not tip since gratituity is already added to your bill in all these places. Only for this people at Carmine's, you may go the extra. Their service and attention meets and exceeds all expectations.
Awesome food and great service.portions are HUGE 3-4 ppl minimum plates
Food look good, but doesn't taste good at all
Meals were good and very large ( we had 9 people and split 3 orders Still to much food). Service was great and not a long walk from Atlantis hotel. They also had live music just outside.
While I probably won't eat here again, it's not because of the food or service. Both were good. Italian food just doesn't fit the island vibe. The best economical order for a family of 3 was 1 lasagna $48. That fed 2 adults and 1 child who eats like a horse. We ate 3/4 of it and was full. The rest was for breakfast and lunch for me and the kid who eats like a horse. After drinks and taxes and gratuity, we spent $84 out the door. See pic. This thing was huge and weighed about 3-5 pounds.
Best Italian food in Nassau .Wow big portions great service , staff was top notch
Food is delicious. Portions are absurdly large. One entree is definitely good enough for 2-3 people. There were 6 of us, and we could barely finish 4 entrees. If you're ordering a meat dish, it comes on top of a bed of spinach, so don't bother with the spinach side.
The service and food were both good. We thoroughly enjoyed this restaurant. And the portions were very large. The three of us easily could've split one meal but we wanted variety and got two.
Huge family style Italian with plenty of choices for everyone. Massive portions of Italian favorites.
Service was good. Food was good. Of the restaurants we explored at Atlantis, we thought this was the best with the kids.
Experience was mediocre at best. They name the same dish 3 different names and just remove a different ingredient from each dish. Food tastes like high-school cafeteria food and all of the servers act like the local lunch lady! One of the worst experiences at a restaurant ever. Overall " the Atlantis" resort sucks major ass!
What a great restaurant. The food was amazing and gigantic portions. We had the best server of our entire stay in Atlantis here. His name is DonPedro. He was excellent and made our anniversary dinner even more special. His service was top notch and very memorable. I couldn't have asked for better service from him. A huge thank you!