About

Tags : #Food., #PointOfInterest, #Establishment

Location :
1 Main St, Garnerville, NY 10923, USA

Opening Hours

  • Monday 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Tuesday 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Wednesday 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Thursday 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Friday 10:00 AM – 11:00 PM
  • Saturday 10:00 AM – 11:00 PM
  • Sunday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM

13 Reviews

  • Anynomous
    13 February 2024

    The pizza by the slice is totally different than by the pie. A grandma slice is so much better when bought by itself and not as a pie. I don't like the inconsistency.

  • Anynomous
    10 February 2024

    Best pizza around and great service

  • Anynomous
    04 February 2024

    Pie was made quick, came out delicious and hot. Thin crust, a little well on bottom not like some places that leave it raw. Sauce was very tasty.

  • Anynomous
    29 October 2023

    Try their grandma's pizza or chicken bacon ranch it's amazing

  • Anynomous
    12 October 2023

    Great food, and wonderful service. Great prices too!

  • Anynomous
    06 June 2023

    Placed order over phone. Asked girl if they had buffalo chicken COLD CUTS. She said "Yes". I then ordered a hero with cheese, a salad and calamari. Came home to find Buffalo chicken breast hot sandwich. Calamari was so well done it was hard. Called on phone to complain and was told they don't have cold cuts. I told the kid that the girl said they did when I placed order. Also when i went to pick it up, i waited over 25 minutes. NEVER AGAIN.

  • Anynomous
    30 May 2023

    Ordered a large pepperoni pizza and garlic knots for delivery. When the order arrived in 40 minutes, the pizza was already cold. It was sliced very sloppily and the pepperonis were not baked into the cheese. They clearly took an old plain pizza and poorly reheated it with pepperonis on top. This place used to make great fresh pizza but just sent us leftover garbage. We ordered at 7:25 on a Saturday, I wonder how many other poor people were sent cold pizzas tonight... Needless to say but I will not be re-ordering from OIP.

  • Anynomous
    17 May 2023

    Clean, friendly staff, fair priced. Amazing food. Definitely try the wings. They are meaty! Very nice owner.

  • Anynomous
    27 February 2024

    Good pizza, friendly staff what more could yout ask for.

  • Anynomous
    18 February 2024

    Great food, BUT if you want COLD FOOD COLD PIZZA FOR YOUR KIDS THEN CALL THIS PLACE, I WAITED 1HR 29MINS BEFORE MY FOOD ARRIVED. AFTER BEING TOLD IT WOULD BE 45MINS MAX. I CALLED BACK TWICE WHILE I WAITED AND BOTH TIMES WAS TOLD FOOD HAD LEFT 20MINS AGO, THEN GET A CALL FROM DRIVER TELLING ME HE NEEDS AN ADDITION 10MINS WHEN FOOD ARRIVED WINGS AND GARLIC KNOTS WHERE COLD ENOUGH TO BE IN SOMEONES DRINK, I ENDED UP MAKING MAC N CHEESE FOR THE KIDS. THANKS ALOT ORIGINALS AND TRUST ME THIS ISN'T THE FIRST TIME JUST THE LAST TIME.

    SINCERLY YOURS
    PISSED OFF 5 YEAR LONG CUSTOMER

  • Anynomous
    27 September 2023

    Great food good service never had a problem

  • Anynomous
    16 September 2023

    I go their almost everyday the pizza is delicious. the people there are really nice. the only thing is its really small but overall everything is perfect

  • Anynomous
    19 June 2023

    Great food great place called for a deliver at 3:20 and "Chris" said there is a 15 dollar minimum I live 2 min down the road from them and order at least 2 to 3 times a week !! Not anymore "Chris"