City Cellar

Location :

Time Zone: America/New_York
Price: $$$
Credit Cards: Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating: Yes
Breakfast: Breakfast
Brunch: Brunch
Lunch: Lunch
Dinner: Dinner
Happy Hour: Happy Hour
Wine: Wine
Cocktails: Cocktails

• Anynomous

  02 December 2023

  Had an odd chain-y vibe even though this is apparently the only one. Food was okay... nothing to write home about. Desserts were a really nice surprise and staff was friendly. Overall, ehh.

• Anynomous

  05 February 2024

  Chicken and waffles and the kobe beef sliders are delicious.

• Anynomous

  13 November 2023

  Food is great, plus a nice wine selection. Check them out for lunch/brunch too!

• Anynomous

  16 April 2023

  Food was good. On weekend they combine to have a brunch menu. Not a big selection for either one.

• Anynomous

  05 October 2023

  Filet mignon was excellent and perfectly cooked.

• Anynomous

  02 June 2023

  Mediocre food and service. Menu used to be better before being changed.

• Anynomous

  14 November 2023

  Mediocre food presentation and AWFUL service from PETER. Sit elsewhere.

• Anynomous

  29 August 2023

  Glazed Shrimp and scallops served over risotto with a glass of Pinot Grigio ...this Restaraunt is hitting on all cylinders!! All I can say is OMG

• Anynomous

  29 August 2023

  Must order for seafood lovers.....Crab crusted Seabass ...albeit pricey great entree for a Long Island Restaraunt . Great ambiance and food

• Anynomous

  21 April 2023

  One of my favorite dinner spots on L.I... But......Very disappointed they took the pork chops off the menu :(

• Anynomous

  22 April 2024

  New owners, larger menu, updated decor. Food was delicious! We loved the truffle flatbread and lobster mac and cheese. All wine over $75 is half off on Monday. Get the 2010 Belle Glos Pinot Noir!

• Anynomous

  18 July 2023

  Amazing food & a huge wine selection!

• Anynomous

  18 May 2023

  Great selection of wine and cool interior!

• Anynomous

  18 April 2024

  Come for the sea bass, stay for the wine <3

• Anynomous

  31 August 2023

  Great management, excellent service and exceptional food. Highly recommend the wine list!

• Anynomous

  02 August 2023

  Okay banana cream doughnuts are a must for dessert. The specials are always outstanding. But the crabmeat crusted chilean sea bass is the best!!!

• Anynomous

  19 May 2023

  Ask to sit near the bar for best acoustics and awesome view of wine cellar!

• Anynomous

  21 January 2024

  Good food and great wine selection! Service is inconsistent.